Reply to Which macro lens?

Lenzflair posted a reply:

I've used all 3 offerings.



35mm - great value, but short working distance - very sharp

50mm 1:2 without EX-25 - extremely sharp - doubles as portrait lens

105mm about 12" of working distance at 1:1, cost effective - very sharp



35mm





50mm





105mm





Sigma working distance at 1:1